Tapping Lands & Casting Spells

I love Magic: The Gathering.  I got addicted to the card game in the late 90s when it was the de-facto thing for my friend group to do on the floor of the gym in the time between when the school bus dropped us off and the bell first rang.  And in downtime during classes.  And at lunch. And after school.  

It was late 1999 when I got hooked.  My parents were a little hesitant. My dad likely because he was well aware of what sort of money sink a collectable hobby could be (he had briefly collected: sports cards, stamps, comic books, coins, probably countless other things that an addictive personality would get wrapped up in in the 80s and 90s).  My mom because magic was one of those evil demonic games that corrupted young boys into devil worship or some shit.  She eventually got over it when she met all my magic playing friends and most of them were also in my gifted/honors courses and made good grades.  Most of them, haha.

My first LGS was called the Gamer's Conclave in Mandeville, Louisiana.  That places still feels like magic.  The big case full of singles cards (who buys those when you can just buy packs). They also had a whole lan setup where I begrudgingly played Counterstrike because that's what everyone else wanted to play (even though I preferred Team Fortress Classic).

 
The Gamer's Conclave circa 2001, Courtesy of the Internet Archive

 

When I moved from Mandeville to Orlando in my high school years, I didn't have an LGS for a while until I discovered Sci-Fi City. This was a huge sprawling store with Warhammer and other battle games, RPG tabletops, board games, and rows upon rows of tables for magic.  These were the true days of classic kitchen table multiplayer magic: 12 person games where everyone's practically going at the same time, echos of "Howling Mine!" or "Mana Flare!" to let the rest of the table know when something that affected us all showed up.  Choruses of Boos when someone played a deck that was a netdeck.

Sci Fi City - Storefront - Comic Books Near Me - Orlando, Florida Sci Fi City - Board game station. - Comic Books Near Me - Orlando, Florida
SCi-Fi City circa 2014 & 2019 (respectively), Courtesy of Yelp.  

 Sci-Fi city is where I really started to gain friends via magic, rather than gaining magic via friends.  But soon I learned of shops that were dedicated to card games.  While Sci-Fi city and places like Coliseum of Comics had packs and cards, it was Gathering Place Games that really got me into not just magic, but competitive magic.  Sci Fi city had comics, wargaming, figures, game tables, computer LAN, etc...but no real "magic events".  It was just people that got together on saturdays to game all day.  

But when I discovered "The Gathering Place", which we colloquially referred to as "Jose's" (the owner of the shop) everything changed.  Jose was all about card games.  The entire store was wall to wall card cases with pokemon, yugioh, and magic for sale.  They had an entire back room where they played this wild thing called Friday Night Magic.  It was so cool.  They had a huge stock of magic singles, so if you needed a card, you could just go up to them and ask for it, and they'd find it and let you pay.  Wild concept!  Now I could make decks out of cards I knew about, not just cards I had in my boxes and binders.

The Gathering Place is where I first ran into the sort of people you always hear about.  The Regulars.  The Hustlers.  The Favorites.  The people who spent a lot of money at the store and thus had earned the favor of the boss.  Was it as bad as that? Well, when the owner of the store goes by The Godfather...yeah.  But it was my first time really experiencing competitive magic, and learned how to try to build decks and really try to compete.

After a couple years of being more or less a nobody in the community, I had my first big magic break.  It was the 2004 Regional Championships.  Affinity was running rampant over the standard metagame, a deck all about throwing out cheap creatures, drawing a ton of cards with Skullclamp, and winning either through combat damage or comboing off with Disciple of the Vault.  The rest of the format was a mixture of decks: Goblins, an aggressive mono-red deck, various flavors of Mono White and Blue/White control, as well as White/Red astral slide control, Tooth and Nail, a deck all about getting certain combinations of lands into play and then rushing out huge impactful creatures, and then the various rogue decks.

What deck was I playing at the time?  Green/Red Land Destruction.  At the time, local pro Billy Postlethwaite had written about a deck that he called Viva La Mexico, which was a green/red land destruction deck that utilized Beasts and Contested Cliffs in order to shut down opposing creature strategies.  He didn't hate the deck, but didn't decide to pursue it.  I liked the overall concept, but I was a big fan of the newly released card Trinisphere.  This is a 3 mana artifact that basically forces. your opponent to pay at least 3 mana for any spell they cast.  My thought was, if I play land destruction and keep my opponents under 3 lands, they won't be able to cast spells! A classic Prison archtype decks.

When I got to the tournament, the Regular Locals all asked what I was playing. I said "g/r land destruction with trinisphere, i cut some of the random beasts for more LD (land destruction)".  Everyone laughed.  

At round 5 I was undefeated.  Then I suffered my first lost.

I rallied back, won two more games... 

And then suffered three defeats back, to back, to back. 

I was crushed.  I lost twice to Goblins, which I knew going in was my worst match up.  I lost twice to Affinity, and both times it was due to me making mistakes because I wasn't able to properly test the match up to know what to prioritize.  Every time I lost I learned something, but that deep into the tournament I was playing against people who knew exactly what to do, and captured on my inexperience.

I was devastated.  I was on the verge of gaining respect, but after crashing out, those who had long since dropped out of the tournament turned their misfortune onto me and ragged on me for blowing my lead.  I went home and bitterly wrote a tournament report, trashing the locals for never testing with me, blaming them for my failings. I can't imagine why they didn't rally to my side after my performance.  

Oh, yeah. I also started writing for their website.  I had a couple deck techs (poorly written) and a couple tournament reports.   I've dug up some of those and they are just so cringe.

After a while I started to become a bit jaded.  The card shops started feeling like another realm of high school. There were cliques at my fun nerd space?  But it was the only place in town that did competitive magic, and I had basically abandoned kitchen table and casual magic.

Queue: Cool Stuff Games.  These days in the Florida and even online magic scene, it wasn't a huge name.  Cool Stuff Inc was an online retailer of board games and tcg products.  Apparently they had been based out of Florida for a while and decided to try out the brick and mortar space in addition to their website.  We instantly fell in love with the atmosphere of the store.  It was friendlier, they tried to keep "cliques" out of it or letting people muscle out people, their prize support and customer service was better, it was our home base store for so long.

Many decks came and went.  I kept trying my hand at writing articles, including a back-to-back article series about the deck I played at 2004 States: Mono-Green Tooth and Nail powered by Vernal Bloom.  

During this time, IRC had established itself as kind of the defacto "king" of online chat rooms.  Maybe just in the nerd space, but online chats like yahoo chats or any other chat service didn't hold the same sway.  mIRC became my go-to chat program and I'd spend hours upon hours just chatting away with online strangers-turned-friends.  At the time, StarCityGames was one of the biggest, if not the biggest, online website about magic the gathering.  I was part of their IRC chat, including a view others.  In one of the chats, people were talking about the best builds of Tooth And Nail and I was trying to advocate for Vernal Bloom.  The editor of SCG at the time, Ted Knutson, claimed that he didn't think it was very good, so I almost played it out of spite. I wrote an article about my build of the deck, which thankfully has been saved by the internet archive: The Bloomin' Onion - The Right Way to Build Mono-Green Tooth? .  I even did a follow-up article where I went over the changes I had made and the tournament report! Sundering Tater: Fatties Rolling Through The Competition At Florida States.

An author's aside: man, it's rough looking back on my writing style. I was too busy trying to be funny and most of the time missing the mark. I think there was a solid core to the tournament report, but I tried to shoehorn in too many references and pop culture quips.  It also is rather evident that I never proofread stuff before I submit things: lots of random weird typos and misnaming of stuff.  Ugh

Shortly after this I started college and spent far too much time playing magic than doing school-based things.  Needless to say, my first year of college is both a blur as well as a resounding failure: I didn't work very hard, got politely asked to take a break and re-assess my academic career, and moved back in with my parents.  Moving from Orlando to the Pensacola area of Florida was a shock to my system, my personal life, my relationships, and my magic career.

I'll dip into some of the others more later, maybe, but for now, I'll concentrate on magic.  In Orlando I was always an "on the verge of".  While I did well at Friday Night Magic, I never really had a breakthrough performance at a big tournament.  I'd always be just outside of any sort of notoriety-birthing finishes, my articles no longer got any attention from the editors (in hindsight: rightfully so).  While I was a rogue deck brewer, I didn't have the talent or the resources to push those decks into the limelight.

The closest I have as far as fame to my name (which inevitably had zero connection to my name) was Grand Prix Boston, 2005.  GP Boston was an extended tournament, and I had been online in some of my various IRC channels where we were talking about an extended version of a vintage deck archtype: Cerebral Assassin.  CA was a deck that revolved around putting a Sundering Titan into the graveyard and reanimating it as soon as possible.  Someone had seen a decklist similar to in in the extended format, and since I had an unhealthy obsession with Sundering Titan I jumped on the deck.  I gave the decklist to my friend Will Fluery, who was going to GP Boston.  He shared the deck with Keith McLaughlin, who piloted it to a Top 4 finish.  I was very exited to hear this since I felt like I had a part in that deck getting into his hands...but alas, it was not meant to be.  I wasn't in any sort of inner circle, just a friend of a friend.

Moving to Pensacola, I looked for a local card shop.  Only I couldn't really find one.  The closest they had was a TBS Comics that did friday night drafts.  But I hated drafting.  Turns out, another TBS comics location farther away did standard, so every Friday night I made the trek from either school, or work, or home, up to Pensacola Florida to sling cards.

In Orlando, I was a top 8 regular, but rarely was I a "winner" of the tournament.   Anytime something bigger than a local FNM popped up, I was forever a bridesmaid but never the bride.  In Pensacola this largely didn't change too much...but my "top 8 regular" turned into semi-regular winner.

In Orlando, top 8 splits were frequent.  We'd frequently play 3 rounds, draw 2 rounds into the top 8, and then split the prize and end the night early.  But in Pensacola, this wasn't really a known thing.  I remember getting to my first FNM, winning my first 3 rounds, and then being surprised when my opponent didn't want to draw into the top 8 in the next 2 rounds.  So I played it out, got to the top 8, and asked what the top 8 split looked like.  Again, I was met with blank stares and no answers. So we played it out. I don't recall if I won or not, but over the next few weeks I slowly started infecting others with my ideas.  Instead of 3-0-2 results into a top 8 split, we'd usually have 4-0-1 into top 8, play a round, and then split.  Usually we'd only not split if someone we didn't like (aka the Regular Assholes) would be in the top 4 and we wanted to lock them out of prizes....which while a bit of a dick move, it was how we tried to cultivate a more cooperative and encouraging atmosphere.

I went from Regular Competitor to kind of the King of FNM.  People came to me for deck help.  We tested on thursdays at the local whataburger and I'd be asked to play someone else's deck to give hints and advice.  It felt weird, but it felt good.  But then the first time I left Pensacola to go visit friends in Orlando, I would be in for a rude awakening.  In Pensacola, I was a big fish in a small pond.

But honestly, it was fine.  I was never truly going to be a magic pro: I didn't put in the time to truly perfect my game, I was too interested in building rogue decks than playing the best deck for a tournament, and I hated drafting which was a huge part of pro play.  So being able to have my hobby fund my hobby (winning store credit, cards, and prestige) was sweet.

I tried to play various Regionals and States and other tournaments as they came and went. I even visited the 2006 National Championships with some of those previously mentioned online strangers-turned-friends from IRC!  But I never "won it big". 

To the point where, come 2007, I stopped going to TBS as frequently as I used to.

Lorwyn was a big shift in MTG design.  We got planeswalkers, we got a heavy emphasis on creature-baesd combat rather than spell-based interaction.  Magic felt like it was changing, and I just wasn't enjoying it.  Maybe it was burn out. Maybe it was because some of my regular crew wasn't playing as much.  Maybe it's because I spent more time working and more time doing anirage and con stuff...but magic just fell by the wayside.  To the point where, come some time in 2008, I decided to ship it all out.

That's right, I sold my collection.

I still regret it.

You see, around 2009ish Star City Games started doing something called the SCG Open, which was a series of tournaments that would take place all around the country. They'd typically have 2 tournaments: a Standard tournament on Saturday and a Legacy tournament on Sunday.  Legacy was a format that used the entire MTG card pool, but with many of the most powerful and broken card banned.  With this added support, Legacy exploded in popularity, and specific cards, which for a long time were "expensive" but reasonably priced, exploded in price.  These in particular were the Dual Lands: lands from the first 4 MTG sets (Alpha, Beta, Unlimited, and Revised) that tapped for 2 different colors and could be fetched with fetch lands.  They went from around $10 to $20 a piece...to $100 to $200.  Nowadays they start at 300 or 400 and can go up to nearly $1000, or more if they are rarely printings.

Here's the thing: I had all of them.   When I sold my collection, which I got a cool $1000 for and used it to buy college textbooks, a new laptop, and other stuff, would have quintupled in price had I not sold it.  These days it would probably be enough to buy a card with just the dual lands, maybe a nice down payment on a house.

And of course, around 2009...I got that itch. The desire to start playing again.  Granted I didn't have the time or cards to play magic much, but I did make a random appearance an a Friday Night Magic, borrowing a friend's deck and making Top 4.  It was weird, it scratched the itch to play, but I was still turned off by tournament magic and what standard magic had become.

Enter: Elder Dragon Highlander.  

At this point, this article is getting very long.  And if I don't press "publish" now I never will.  So I hope you enjoy a look through the "first half" of my magic career, spanning about a decade. 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Hello Crickets, We Meet Again

Brodude's Games for Dudes, Bro

Replacing Kerby - A Faux Behind The Scenes